Skip to main content

Meniscus tear

Advertisement

What is a meniscus?

Each knee contains a medial and a lateral meniscus, two crescent-shaped, elastic discs made of fibrocartilage, which lie between the joint surfaces of the thighbone and the shinbone. The medial meniscus is situated on the inner side of the femur, whilst the lateral meniscus is situated on the outer side.

Whilst the lateral meniscus is only partially fused to the joint capsule, the medial meniscus is firmly attached to the joint capsule and the medial collateral ligament, which is why it is less mobile than the lateral meniscus and more prone to injury.

What are the functions of the meniscus?

The menisci fulfil several important functions. Thanks to their smooth cartilaginous surface, they reduce the friction that occurs between the femoral head and the acetabulum during movements of the knee joint. Furthermore, they act as shock absorbers, cushioning the movements within the knee joint. They also ensure that weight and pressure are distributed evenly across the knee joint and guarantee that the joint surfaces of the femur and tibia fit together perfectly.

What is a meniscus tear?

A meniscus tear is a tear-like injury to the fibrocartilaginous discs in the knee and is caused either by external force applied to the knee joint or as a result of degenerative (age-related) wear and tear of the menisci.

Meniscus tears are among the most common sports injuries, with the injury in most cases being caused by a twisting motion of the knee. The medial meniscus is most commonly affected, as it is firmly attached to the joint capsule and the medial collateral ligament and is therefore less mobile. In such sports injuries, other structures within the knee joint may also be damaged, such as the collateral or cruciate ligaments, or bone and cartilage.

Furthermore, a meniscus tear can also result from chronic overuse of the knee joint, particularly among occupational groups who frequently work in a squatting or kneeling position. Degenerative meniscus injuries often occur from the age of 40 onwards, when natural wear and tear of the menisci begins. As a result of this degeneration, the meniscus tissue can tear even under minimal strain or without any external force being applied

What types of tears are there?

A meniscus tear can run through the tissue in any direction. The most common types of tear are the basket-handle tear and the radial tear, whilst horizontal tears are less common.

  • Basket-handle tear: The tear runs lengthways through the meniscus and is not connected to the inner edge. The length of the tear can vary and sometimes extends over half the length of the meniscus. This type of tear can lead to impingement symptoms.
  • Radial tear: The tear originates at various points along the inner edge of the meniscus and extends outwards to varying degrees along the radius of the meniscus.
  • Lobed tear: In a lobed tear, the inner edge of the meniscus is torn. The inner portion of the meniscus, which has become detached in a lobed manner, can cause blockages and impingement symptoms.
  • Horizontal tear: Horizontal tears mainly affect the posterior horn of the meniscus and cause pain, but do not result in impingement symptoms.

What are the symptoms of a meniscus tear?

A meniscus tear caused by an injury leads to swelling of the knee and acute knee pain. This is different from meniscus tears caused by degenerative wear and tear. These do not present as an acute knee injury, but they accelerate cartilage loss in the knee joint.

The following symptoms may indicate a meniscus tear:

  • sharp, sudden pain in the knee joint
  • swelling of the knee joint
  • Cracking or snapping sounds in the knee joint
  • Restricted movement
  • A feeling that the knee is locking
  • Instability of the knee joint

How is a meniscus tear diagnosed?

If a meniscus tear is suspected, the first step is a medical history interview, during which the doctor will ask about current symptoms and any accident that may have caused the injury, or particular occupational strain on the knee.

During the physical examination, the patient’s gait may indicate a weight-bearing limp. A pressure test can reveal whether the affected joint space is tender to pressure. Various functional tests, in which the affected meniscus is placed under tension and the knee is bent, straightened and rotated in different positions, are used to assess mobility and identify any restrictions. At the same time, the stability of the ligaments is also checked to identify any possible ligament injuries.

An X-ray cannot show a meniscus tear, but is nevertheless often carried out to rule out other problems such as osteoarthritis or fractures. A magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan often provides crucial information for a definitive diagnosis.

What treatment options are available?

The choice of treatment depends on the type and extent of the meniscus injury. Not every meniscus tear requires surgery. Often, the meniscus is not completely torn; if it is stable and the tissue has not shifted, it can heal on its own. For minor meniscus injuries that do not cause instability in the knee, or in the case of degenerative meniscus tears, conservative treatment is often used.

During the acute phase, it is important to rest the knee until the pain and swelling subside. Crutches or support bandages may also be used for this purpose. Anti-inflammatory medication (such as diclofenac or ibuprofen) and regular cooling of the knee are further supportive measures.

Once the acute phase of pain and swelling has passed, physiotherapy is often prescribed. Its aim is to strengthen the thigh muscles, stabilise the knee joint and restore its function. Surgery for a meniscus tear is usually carried out if the tear causes severe symptoms, the knee locks or swells repeatedly, other knee structures such as ligaments are injured, or conservative treatment has not been successful.

A distinction is made between the following surgical procedures:

  • Partial meniscectomy (partial removal of the meniscus): This is usually carried out arthroscopically and is performed as gently as possible in order to preserve as much meniscus tissue as possible. In the case of a basket-handle tear, the inner part of the meniscus is removed by extending the posterior and anterior margins of the tear right up to the inner edge of the meniscus. A radial tear is excised in a semicircular shape. In the case of a horizontal tear, the torn section is also removed in an arc-shaped incision.
  • Meniscus repair (meniscus suture): This is also usually performed arthroscopically and is possible where the meniscus receives a sufficient blood supply to allow the tear to heal. This is often the case with bucket-handle tears.
  • Meniscus replacement: In this procedure, the damaged meniscus is completely removed and replaced with an artificial meniscus. This method is only used if all other treatment attempts have been unsuccessful or if the meniscus is irreparably damaged.

After treatment

The follow-up care for a meniscus tear depends on the individual’s symptoms and on whether a partial meniscus resection or meniscus suturing was performed.

Following a partial meniscus resection, no strict follow-up treatment is usually required. The operated leg can bear partial weight with the aid of forearm crutches just a few days after the procedure. Full weight-bearing is often possible after one to two weeks, and sporting activities can normally be resumed after around six to eight weeks. It is recommended that patients carry out accompanying physiotherapy exercises.

In the case of meniscus suturing, the recovery period is significantly longer, as the sutured meniscus needs time to heal. The knee should only bear partial weight for the first four to six weeks after the operation, and movement must be restricted so as not to put strain on the suture. Full weight-bearing is usually only possible six weeks after the procedure, and a full return to sport is generally only possible around four months after the operation. Intensive physiotherapy is essential in all cases.

Further important information on meniscus tears can be found in our expert consultation with Dr Christian Gäbler.

  • Author

    Gernot Hofer

More on this topic
Hormones

Low testosterone in men: symptoms, causes and treatment

Fatigue, a reduced sex drive, and a lack of energy: these symptoms can have many causes. One possible explanation is a testosterone deficiency. However, it is not possible to determine whether testosterone levels are actually too low based solely on the symptoms or on a single blood test result.

Men's health
Men's health

PSA level: What does it mean, and when is it too high?




The PSA level is one of the best-known laboratory test results relating to the prostate. Many men come across it for the first time during a screening examination or when having symptoms investigated. An abnormal result often raises questions: Is this already a sign of prostate cancer? What levels are considered normal?

Prostate
Pollen allergy

The right diet for hay fever

Anyone suffering from hay fever should pay particular attention to their diet so as not to make the symptoms any worse.

Nutrition
Urology

Prostate health: What men need to know

The prostate is a gland in a man’s body that is only the size of a chestnut, but it plays a crucial role in well-being, urinary function and male sexuality. Benign enlargement and prostate cancer become more common in older age.

Prostate