Skip to main content

Fluoride in toothpaste: essential protection or toxic to children?

Advertisement

What are fluorides?

Fluorides are fluorine compounds, i.e. chemical compounds that contain the element fluorine. They consist, for example, of sodium or calcium and fluorine. They are usually salts whose structure is similar to that of table salt (sodium chloride). Fluorides occur in nature in low concentrations. In dentistry, fluorides are used in toothpastes, dental gels and mouthwashes to help prevent tooth decay.

Occurrence in nature

Fluorides occur both in the form of minerals in nature and within the human body. Good dietary sources of fluoride include, for example, black tea and sea fish. Smaller amounts are found in cereals, liver and meat. Drinking water, mineral water and fluoridated table salt also contribute to fluoride intake.

In the human body, fluoride – usually bound to calcium – is stored in bones and teeth. It plays an important role in the formation and maintenance of the skeleton and teeth.

How does fluoride work?

Fluoride is best known for its caries-preventing effect and has been well researched in this area: it is incorporated into the tooth enamel and hardens it, making it more resistant to acids that damage teeth. Fluoride also inhibits the metabolic processes of the bacteria responsible for the development of tooth decay. Furthermore, it promotes the remineralisation of tooth enamel and strengthens it when it has been attacked by acids.

Apart from this, there is evidence to suggest that fluoride may influence bone metabolism and possibly help prevent osteoporosis. However, the evidence on this topic is less conclusive than that regarding its dental effects.

In what forms is fluoride available?

Fluoride is available in various forms. The most common include:

  • Toothpaste: Fluoride is added to toothpastes to strengthen tooth enamel and prevent tooth decay.
  • Mouthwashes: Many mouthwashes contain fluoride to provide additional protection for the teeth and promote oral health.
  • Dental gels: These products are often used for targeted fluoride treatments, for example in cases of increased risk of tooth decay.
  • Tablets: Special fluoride tablets are available for infants and young children to ensure an adequate intake of fluoride.

In addition, fluoridated table salt and fluoridated mineral water are further sources that can contribute to fluoride intake.

What is the difference between fluorine and fluoride?

Fluorine is a highly toxic, corrosive and strongly odourous gas. When combined with other elements such as sodium or calcium, it forms fluoride, a harmless trace element that is particularly important for dental health.

Is fluoride toxic?

The principle here is: ‘It is the dose that makes the poison.’ In small quantities, such as those found in toothpaste, fluoride is extremely effective in preventing tooth decay. However, excessive fluoride intake can lead to white spots or streaks on the teeth (fluorosis) and, in very high doses, can even cause symptoms of poisoning.

What are the side effects of fluoride?

Like any chemical substance, fluoride can also have side effects.

  • Fluorosis: This side effect manifests as white to yellow-brown spots or streaks on the teeth. It affects only infants and pre-school children, as fluorosis can only develop during the enamel formation phase. Even then, it only occurs if the recommended total intake is exceeded over a long period.
  • Toxic effects: An extreme overdose of fluoride can have toxic effects. These can result, for example, from swallowing large quantities of fluoride-containing oral care products. However, such signs of poisoning are rare and usually manifest only as temporary symptoms such as dizziness, diarrhoea or nausea.
  • Skeletal fluorosis: Long-term intake of extremely high levels of fluoride can lead to skeletal fluorosis, a condition associated with joint pain and stiffness. 

How much fluoride do we need?

Fluoride requirements depend on age and gender.

  • Babies need very little, around 0.25 mg per day
  • Children and adolescents up to the age of 15: requirements increase with age and range from 0.7 mg to 2.7 mg per day.
  • Adults: Women require around 3.0 mg per day, men 3.5 mg per day.

These amounts are usually met through a combination of diet (e.g. fluoridated salt, black tea, sea fish), drinks (such as fluoridated mineral water) and toothpaste.

Recommendations on fluoride content in toothpastes

  • Adults: It is recommended to brush teeth twice daily with a toothpaste containing 1.0–1.5 mg/cm³ (1,000–1,500 ppm) of fluoride.
  • Children: For children, a toothpaste with a fluoride content of 1,000 ppm is recommended.

(Note: ppm stands for ‘parts per million’. 1,000 ppm is equivalent to 0.1 per cent.)

Why is fluoride in toothpaste?

Fluoride is an important ingredient in toothpaste and plays a crucial role in dental health. It has been used for decades because it is one of the most effective ways of preventing tooth decay. Since the introduction of fluoride toothpaste in the 1950s, the incidence of tooth decay among children and young people has fallen significantly.

Fluoride strengthens tooth enamel by making it more resistant to acids. It also supports remineralisation, which means it helps to repair minor damage to the enamel.

Scientific studies on fluoride

Fluoride is one of the most thoroughly researched substances in medicine. There are around 300,000 scientific studies and meta-analyses on this topic. The overwhelming majority of these conclude that fluoride is highly effective in preventing tooth decay. Concerns regarding possible adverse effects relate primarily to excessive fluoride intake.

Fluoride for babies and children

Dental experts recommend the use of fluoride even for babies and young children. The basic fluoride regimen is as follows:

  • Infants (from birth until teeth erupt):
    One combined preparation daily containing 0.25 mg of fluoride and 400–500 IU of vitamin D in tablet form.
  • Toddlers (from the time teeth start to come through until 12 months):
    One tablet daily containing 400–500 IU of vitamin D and brushing teeth up to twice a day with a rice-grain-sized amount of children’s fluoride toothpaste (1,000 ppm).
  • Toddlers (12 months to under 2 years):
    Brush teeth twice a day using a rice-grain-sized amount of fluoride children’s toothpaste (1,000 ppm).
  • Children (2 to 6 years):
    Brush teeth two to three times a day using a pea-sized amount of fluoride children’s toothpaste (1,000 ppm).
  • Children (aged 6 and over):
    Brush teeth twice a day with fluoride toothpaste for teenagers or adults (1,000–1,500 ppm).

Protection against tooth decay: How fluoride strengthens tooth enamel

Fluoride acts as a protective shield for the teeth. It binds with calcium from the saliva to form a resilient layer on the tooth surface. This layer protects the enamel from acids produced by bacteria that cause tooth decay.

Fluoride also penetrates the enamel and strengthens it from within. It supports remineralisation and helps to repair minor damage to the enamel.

Toothpaste with or without fluoride?

Toothpaste with fluoride Toothpaste without fluoride
Advantages Effective protection
against tooth decay Protection against harmful acids
Remineralisation and hardening of the enamel
Contains mainly natural ingredients
; no risk of toxicity or fluorosis
Disadvantages May be
toxic if consumed in extreme quantities May lead to fluorosis if taken alongside additional fluoride
Some ingredients may damage
tooth enamel Insufficient protection against tooth decay in people prone to tooth decay or with exposed tooth necks

Who is fluoride-free toothpaste suitable for?

Fluoride-free toothpaste can be a good alternative for certain groups of people:

  • Infants and young children:
    Very young children are at increased risk of swallowing too much fluoride. At this age, it may be advisable to administer fluoride via tablets whilst using fluoride-free toothpaste.
  • People with a fluoride allergy:
    People with a confirmed allergy to fluoride should use fluoride-free toothpaste to avoid allergic reactions.

What alternatives are there to fluoride?

Fluoride is still considered the most effective protection against tooth decay, yet many people are interested in alternatives. Some of these are:

  • Toothpaste containing activated charcoal:
    This toothpaste is primarily known as a ‘whitening agent’, as it removes plaque and brightens the tooth surface. However, with long-term use, activated charcoal toothpastes can roughen the teeth, which encourages the formation of new plaque.
  • Toothpaste containing xylitol:
    Xylitol is a sugar substitute that contains around 40 per cent fewer calories than sugar. It is used in food, drinks and oral care products and is said to inhibit cavity-causing bacteria. Although xylitol has a positive effect, it is not as effective against tooth decay as fluoride.
  • Toothpaste with tea tree oil:
    This toothpaste is often recommended for gum inflammation or sores in the mouth. It has anti-inflammatory properties and helps combat discolouration. However, it offers less protection against tooth decay than fluoride-containing toothpaste.

Fluoride-free toothpaste: effectiveness and limitations

Fluoride-free toothpastes are usually made from natural ingredients and contain carefully selected substances that can care for the teeth and inhibit the growth of bacteria. However, they do not offer the same protection against tooth decay as fluoride-containing toothpastes. Remineralisation of tooth enamel is also less effective with fluoride-free products.

Anyone who opts for fluoride-free toothpaste should pay particular attention to a diet that promotes dental health. Consumption of sugary and acidic foods and drinks should be kept to a minimum, as these can increase the risk of tooth decay.

Fluoride toothpaste in Öko-Test

The consumer magazine Öko-Test assesses products and services objectively, neutrally and expertly. Its verdict on fluoride in toothpaste is clear:

“Fluoride in toothpaste is normally not only harmless but actually essential for ensuring adequate protection against tooth decay. Only those who eat toothpaste by the tubeful or consume too much fluoride over many years put themselves at risk.”

In its latest test, Öko-Test assessed 48 toothpastes. Products without fluoride were given lower ratings, as fluoride is considered an essential component for protection against tooth decay. Some of the toothpastes that achieved a very good overall rating include Alverde 5-in-1 Nanamine Toothpaste, Bioturm Organic Mint Toothpaste with Fluoride, Dentalux 3-Fold Protection Fresh Gel and Eurodont Coolfresh Toothpaste. The full test results and details of all the products tested can be found here:
Öko-Test toothpaste test.

  • Author

    Gernot Hofer

More on this topic
Hormones

Low testosterone in men: symptoms, causes and treatment

Fatigue, a reduced sex drive, and a lack of energy: these symptoms can have many causes. One possible explanation is a testosterone deficiency. However, it is not possible to determine whether testosterone levels are actually too low based solely on the symptoms or on a single blood test result.

Men's health
Men's health

PSA level: What does it mean, and when is it too high?




The PSA level is one of the best-known laboratory test results relating to the prostate. Many men come across it for the first time during a screening examination or when having symptoms investigated. An abnormal result often raises questions: Is this already a sign of prostate cancer? What levels are considered normal?

Prostate
Pollen allergy

The right diet for hay fever

Anyone suffering from hay fever should pay particular attention to their diet so as not to make the symptoms any worse.

Nutrition
Urology

Prostate health: What men need to know

The prostate is a gland in a man’s body that is only the size of a chestnut, but it plays a crucial role in well-being, urinary function and male sexuality. Benign enlargement and prostate cancer become more common in older age.

Prostate