Skip to main content

Depression in men

Advertisement

Depression manifests itself differently in men than in women: men affected by it often display symptoms that are atypical of depression and are at a higher risk of suicide. At the same time, the condition is frequently not recognised as such in men. However, early treatment by a specialist is crucial for the course of the illness and recovery.

How does depression in men differ from that in women?

Thanks to gender studies, it is now widely recognised that there are significant differences in the health of men and women. The details, however, are less well known, and this is particularly true of the differences between the sexes when it comes to mental health and, specifically, depression. For a long time, it was assumed that women were affected by depression far more frequently than men, and it is only in recent years that scientific studies have shown this not to be the case.

It is now generally accepted that men are just as likely as women to develop depression, yet male patients exhibit different symptoms, some of which are not yet fully captured by the standard diagnostic criteria. For example, symptoms such as irritability, aggression and outbursts of anger are typical of male depression, whilst the classic symptoms associated with depression – such as a lack of motivation, low mood and a lack of joy are also present in men, but are overshadowed by the other symptoms and only become apparent late in the course of the illness. This, in turn, explains why depression is so frequently underdiagnosed in men. 

Another reason for this is that men also have different health-related behaviours to women. They are far less likely to seek help of their own accord, tend to suppress the condition and often attribute depressive symptoms to stress and work-related pressures, without considering that these might be mental health issues or a depressive disorder. Consequently, even doctors are often unable to recognise that a man is suffering from depression; moreover, men often only consult them once physical symptoms such as exhaustion, insomnia or a feeling of burnout have set in.  

Other common characteristics of male depression include co-occurring substance use disorders and a tendency towards suicide using violent methods. The suicide rate among men is around three times higher than among women, although women are more likely to attempt suicide.  

As far as the treatment of depression in men is concerned, it is unfortunately the case that they often try to self-medicate with alcohol and performance-enhancing drugs, which usually only leads them deeper into depression. Yet professional therapy could also be of great help to them: depression can now be treated effectively with antidepressants and psychotherapy. 

Male depression: what are the causes?  

The causes of depression are always individual, and there are numerous factors involved in the development of the condition. According to the biopsychosocial model, there are genetic and biological risk factors on the one hand, and psychological and social factors on the other. Psychosocial risk factors that can trigger depression or anxiety in men include, amongst others: 

  • physical illnesses 
  • relationship problems
  • work-related problems and stress
  • loneliness or a feeling of being excluded
  • significant life changes (e.g. divorce)
  • Pregnancy of one’s partner and the birth of a child
  • Drug and alcohol use

In addition, there are groups of men who are particularly at risk. These include, for example, young men aged between 16 and 24, men experiencing fatherhood for the first time under difficult circumstances, or older men who, for example, are affected by serious physical illnesses, suffer from the side effects of medication, experience loss and loneliness, or have to cope with major changes such as moving into a care home. Men who face difficult working conditions or are unemployed also have an increased risk of developing depression. The same applies to men who have to cope with unexpected losses of income and consequently suffer from anxiety about the future; and, last but not least, alcohol and drug use are often a contributing factor in the onset of depression or may be a consequence of it. 

Male depression – what are the symptoms?  

Essentially, depression is a mental health disorder characterised not by a single symptom, but by a variety of symptoms – known as depressive symptoms. These include a markedly low mood, a loss of interest and a lack of motivation over an extended period. In addition, patients often suffer from a wide variety of physical complaints, and those affected are usually impaired in all aspects of their daily lives by their condition; they have difficulty coping with everyday tasks, suffer from severe self-doubt and concentration problems, and ruminate a great deal. This is associated with a high level of psychological distress. 

As regards depressive disorders in men, recent studies show that the condition can often be masked by behaviour atypical of depression, such as increased aggression, irritability, anti-social behaviour, or addictive and risky behaviour. 

Typical symptoms and behavioural changes in men with depression include: 

  • Addictive behaviour (work, sport, alcohol, the internet, sex, etc.)
  • Risky behaviour
  • Social withdrawal
  • Denial of sadness or mental health problems
  • insistent demand for autonomy
  • Refusal to accept help from others
  • Increasing frequency of outbursts of anger 
  • Increasing aggression
  • Hostility

Male depression: How can it be diagnosed? 

Generally speaking, the diagnosis of depression begins with a consultation with the patient and a review of their medical history. The symptoms are specifically enquired about – using specialised questionnaires – and a physical examination is carried out. In addition, laboratory tests, CT scans, MRI scans of the brain and ultrasound scans of the blood vessels supplying the brain may be ordered. 

It is also important to note that depression is generally regarded as a condition that predominantly affects women, and that the condition is less frequently recognised and treated in men. Experts attribute this under-diagnosis to various reasons: on the one hand, men are less likely to seek professional help, often conform to norms of traditional masculinity and typical defence mechanisms, and frequently present primarily with physical symptoms. For them, depression is often not an issue. On the other hand, the diagnostic criteria for depression focus on ‘typically female symptoms’, which are reported less frequently by men. Furthermore, the experts cite structural shortcomings in the healthcare system, communication breakdowns in doctor-patient interactions, and the continuing social stigma surrounding mental health conditions as reasons for the inadequate diagnosis and treatment of depression in men. They therefore call for better and earlier identification of men with depression, a men-sensitive approach to diagnosing depression right from primary care, efforts to ensure men-sensitive doctor-patient communication, and treatment in line with clinical guidelines, particularly for men. 

Male depression – how is it treated? 

Men often tend to view depression not as an illness but as a sign of weakness. This is one reason why they frequently attempt to self-medicate using alcohol, performance-enhancing substances or even illegal drugs; however, this usually leads them even deeper into depression. 

Professional treatment involves the use of medication (various antidepressants) and psychotherapy. A combination of both approaches is often successful, and in cases of mild to moderate depression, psychotherapy alone may be sufficient. 

Other additional treatment measures include, amongst others: 

  • Occupational therapy
  • Physiotherapy
  • Light therapy
  • Treatment with St John’s wort extract (mild depression) 
  • Electroconvulsive therapy, if necessary (severe depression that does not respond to any other method)
  • Author

    Gernot Hofer

More on this topic
Hormones

Low testosterone in men: symptoms, causes and treatment

Fatigue, a reduced sex drive, and a lack of energy: these symptoms can have many causes. One possible explanation is a testosterone deficiency. However, it is not possible to determine whether testosterone levels are actually too low based solely on the symptoms or on a single blood test result.

Men's health
Men's health

PSA level: What does it mean, and when is it too high?




The PSA level is one of the best-known laboratory test results relating to the prostate. Many men come across it for the first time during a screening examination or when having symptoms investigated. An abnormal result often raises questions: Is this already a sign of prostate cancer? What levels are considered normal?

Prostate
Pollen allergy

The right diet for hay fever

Anyone suffering from hay fever should pay particular attention to their diet so as not to make the symptoms any worse.

Nutrition
Urology

Prostate health: What men need to know

The prostate is a gland in a man’s body that is only the size of a chestnut, but it plays a crucial role in well-being, urinary function and male sexuality. Benign enlargement and prostate cancer become more common in older age.

Prostate