Antisocial personality disorder – what is it?
Antisocial personality disorder is characterised by those affected consistently disregarding social norms and ruthlessly pursuing their own goals. This behaviour often becomes apparent as early as childhood and adolescence: rules are flouted, school is frequently skipped, and there are instances of theft, wilful destruction and lying. In adulthood, many people with antisocial personality disorder are prone to criminality and violence; they break the law and have a high tolerance for risk. On the other hand, they find it extremely difficult to cope with frustration and often react to it with aggressive and violent behaviour. Punishments or negative experiences do not usually lead those affected to change their behaviour. However, not all people with antisocial personality disorder are criminals; some are well-adjusted socially and successful in their careers. It is also typical for those affected to lack empathy. Consequently, they feel no guilt or sense of responsibility when they harm others. At the same time, they often have a keen ability to recognise the feelings of others and exploit them for their own ends, for example by manipulating them through their particular charm. Antisocial personality disorder must be distinguished from antisocial personality style, which resembles the disorder but is less pronounced. People with an antisocial personality style are generally adventurous and willing to take risks. Self-determined behaviour is particularly important to them; they are very skilful at pursuing their own interests, are often very articulate and act quickly. As a result, they appear socially very competent and often receive a great deal of recognition. In fact, many people with an antisocial personality style are often successful in professions where a willingness to take risks plays a part. According to scientific research, between one and four per cent of the population are affected by antisocial personality disorder, with the disorder being four times more common in men than in women.
What are the causes of antisocial personality disorder?
As with other mental health conditions and personality disorders, it is assumed that the disorder arises from the interaction of biological, psychological and social factors. A possible genetic cause can be assumed, as antisocial personality disorder occurs more frequently when one or both parents have had the disorder. However, psychological and social causes can also be cited, as those affected often come from broken homes and have experienced violence, neglect and a lack of affection during their childhood. Here, however, there is again an interplay of various factors, as the likelihood of antisocial behaviour is increased when a specific gene variant coincides with physical maltreatment or abuse during childhood. This genetic variant is the low-activity form of the so-called MAO-A gene, which results in lower levels of the enzyme monoamine oxidase-A. This, in turn, leads to increased release of the neurotransmitters serotonin, dopamine and noradrenaline in the brain, which can influence aggression and impulsivity. Another risk factor is antisocial behaviour in childhood and adolescence, characterised by physical violence, criminal behaviour, lying and truancy. Similarly, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in childhood appears to increase the risk of this disorder. As far as therapeutic perspectives are concerned, psychoanalysis posits that people with antisocial personality disorder received little parental love during childhood and were therefore unable to develop a basic sense of trust in others. Forming emotional bonds is therefore impossible for them, and they only develop relationships in which they can exert power or behave destructively. Cognitive behavioural therapy, on the other hand, assumes that learning factors also play a role in the development of the disorder. Consequently, it may be the case that those affected have possibly adopted this behaviour from their parents, or that their parents paid particular attention to aggressive behaviour and did not curb inconsiderate, aggressive or selfish behaviour. From this perspective, such behaviour was therefore rewarded, which explains why it subsequently occurs more frequently.
How does antisocial personality disorder manifest itself?
As regards the symptoms of antisocial personality disorder, they are described somewhat differently according to the standard classification systems, the ICD-10 and the DSM. According to the DSM, people with this disorder exhibit a pervasive pattern of disregard for and violation of the rights of others. At least three of the following criteria must be met:
- Those affected are unable to conform to laws and social norms and repeatedly commit acts that constitute grounds for arrest.
- They repeatedly lie, cheat and use aliases, and this behaviour is motivated solely by personal gain or their own pleasure.
- They are impulsive and unable to plan ahead.
- They are irritable and aggressive and are consequently frequently involved in fights or assaults.
- They consistently behave irresponsibly and are, for example, unable to hold down a job or meet financial obligations.
- They show no remorse when they have hurt, abused or stolen from other people. This is evident in their indifference or a rational attitude towards the events.
Please note: These symptoms do not occur in the context of schizophrenia or a manic episode. Unlike the DSM, the ICD-10 – in its description of the disorder – does not focus on criminal acts and breaches of the law, but on typical patterns in experience, behaviour and interpersonal relationships. According to this classification system, people with antisocial personality disorder are egocentric, unempathetic and unscrupulous. Criminal behaviour may occur, but is not essential for the diagnosis. According to the ICD-10, at least three of the following criteria must be met:
- Those affected lack empathy and display emotional coldness towards others.
- They repeatedly disregard social norms.
- They have difficulty forming relationships and bonds with others.
- They have a low tolerance for frustration and often behave impulsively or aggressively.
- They experience little or no guilt and are incapable of social learning.
- They often offer only a superficial explanation for their own behaviour and tend to blame others unjustifiably.
- They are persistently irritable.
Antisocial personality disorder: which doctor should you consult?
As regards the diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder, this is only made by a specialist in psychiatry from the age of 16 onwards. To distinguish the disorder from other illnesses or conditions, blood and urine tests are carried out on a case-by-case basis to determine whether the behaviour is attributable to drug use. A computed tomography (CT) scan can be used to rule out any potential damage to the brain. In addition, questionnaires such as the Structured Clinical Interview (SKID) are used, and family members may also be interviewed where appropriate.
Treatment of antisocial personality disorder
Psychotherapeutic approaches are predominantly used in treatment. They aim to modify characteristics in those affected that may lead to violence, criminal behaviour and aggression. In other words, the aim is to improve interpersonal and social skills, teach better impulse control and foster empathy. An important part of such therapy is also learning strategies that enable those affected to avoid relapsing into old patterns of behaviour. It is also important to note that people with antisocial personality disorder usually do not enter therapy voluntarily, but rather as a result of a court order. For this reason, too, their motivation to ‘participate’ is often not particularly high. It has proved beneficial when the therapist believes in the success of the therapy and conveys this to the patient. Furthermore, he or she needs to adopt a committed approach and should, on the one hand, be responsive to the patient’s perspective, whilst on the other hand setting clear boundaries and maintaining authority over the therapy. A clearly structured approach is also important, and targeted support and aftercare following the actual therapy can help to ensure the therapy’s success in the long term. What has proved to be less successful is, on the one hand, an overly authoritarian, punitive approach and, on the other, an overly lax approach on the part of the therapist, in which the patient is permitted to do almost anything. As regards specific psychotherapeutic approaches, psychoanalytic and depth psychology-based therapies, as well as cognitive behavioural therapy, are used. The former are based on the premise that the therapist should adopt a supportive role and provide a great deal of structure. (Therapeutic approaches with little structure, in which interpretations play a role, are regarded by experts as not very effective.) The latter has so far proved to be the most successful form of therapy for the treatment of antisocial personality disorder. Cognitive behavioural therapy can both reduce criminal behaviour and bring about positive changes in personality traits. Improving social skills is key here. Those affected are guided to learn how to fulfil their own needs whilst at the same time showing consideration for the needs of others. There is also a focus on exercises designed to help them better recognise the wishes and feelings of others, improve self-control, build positive interpersonal relationships and cope better with anger. Another key aspect is developing compassion for the victims of their own actions and taking responsibility for them. Finally, relapse prevention is also practised by devising concrete steps to prevent violent behaviour at the earliest possible stage. As regards the use of psychotropic medication, experts note that it appears to contribute little, if at all, to bringing about an effective and lasting change in antisocial personality disorder.